Homes for Sale $500K to $750K in Nutley, NJ

Nutley is an Essex County township of tree-lined streets and parks, offering an easy commute to both Newark and Manhattan.

Open Full Map Search →
Get New $500K to $750K Homes In Nutley The Day They Hit The Market
Free instant alerts · Unsubscribe anytime
Homes for Sale
66
Median List Price
$649,900
Price Range
$525,000 – $749,900
County
Essex County

Browse Nutley Homes by Price

$500K – $750K (66)

By Bedrooms

2+ Bedroom (17)3+ Bedroom (33)4+ Bedroom (10)5+ Bedroom (5)

66 Homes for Sale $500K to $750K in Nutley, NJ

Active
$625,000
33 Myrtle Ave
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
Active
$599,900
427 Hartford Dr
Nutley, NJ
23.12,010
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
Active
$609,000
124 Hawthorne Ave
Nutley, NJ
32.1
Listed by LATTIMER REALTY
Active
$680,000
456 Hartford Dr
Nutley, NJ
22.2
Listed by RE/MAX SELECT
Coming Soon
$649,900
471 Hartford Dr
Nutley, NJ
22.12,010
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
Active
$745,000
3 Hillside Ave
Nutley, NJ
31.1
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS CITY VIEWS REALTY
Active
$695,000
66 Enclosure St
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS VILLAGE SQUARE
Active
$649,900
31 Freeman Pl
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
Active
$549,000
180 Mountainview Ave
Nutley, NJ
22
Listed by COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
Active
$659,000
19 Orchard St
Nutley, NJ
32.15,001
Listed by RE/MAX REAL ESTATE LIMITED
Under Contract
$549,900
85 Bloomfield Ave
Nutley, NJ
31.1
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS PROSPERITY REALTY
Coming Soon
$550,000
15 Edgar Pl
Nutley, NJ
31
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Coming Soon
$689,000
83 E Centre St
Nutley, NJ
42.2
Listed by AGENCY ON THE AVE
Active
$645,000
34 Milton Ave
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Active
$729,000
84 Howard Pl
Nutley, NJ
332,100
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$660,000
5 Briar Lane
Nutley, NJ
53
Listed by Realty Executives Elite Homes
Under Contract
$699,000
8 Witherspoon St
Nutley, NJ
43
Listed by MONACO REALTY LLC
Under Contract
$660,000
5 Briar Ln
Nutley, NJ
53
Listed by REALTY EXECUTIVES ELITE HOMES
Active
$529,000
10 Glendale St
Nutley, NJ
31.1
Listed by MONACO REALTY LLC
ActiveInternet Data Exchange
$694,900
71 Kierstead Avenue
Nutley, NJ
33
Listed by Keller Williams Village Square Realty
Active
$694,900
71 Kierstead Ave
Nutley, NJ
33
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS VILLAGE SQUARE
Active
$639,000
312 Wilshire Dr
Nutley, NJ
22.22,000
Listed by PREMIUMONE REALTY
Active
$599,000
54 Hancox Ave
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
ActiveInternet Data Exchange
$599,000
54 Hancox Avenue
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by Coldwell Banker, Alpine/Closter
Active
$739,000
222 Vreeland Ave
Nutley, NJ
32.1
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Under Contract
$749,000
29 Oakley Ter
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Active
$699,000
171 Oak Ridge Ave
Nutley, NJ
31.2
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Active
$675,000
347 Winthrop Dr
Nutley, NJ
232,300
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
Active
$659,900
17 Weston St
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by COCCIA REAL ESTATE GROUP, LLC.
Active
$749,900
32 Newman Ave
Nutley, NJ
42.11,812
Listed by A & E CURTINEZ REALTY LLC
Under Contract
$529,000
108-110 Passaic Ave 24C
Nutley, NJ
221,564
Listed by DRI REAL ESTATE CO., INC.
Active
$699,000
100 Hancox Ave
Nutley, NJ
42
Listed by COLDWELL BANKER REALTY
Active
$655,000
15 Oak Ridge Ave
Nutley, NJ
42
Listed by UNITED REAL ESTATE
Under Contract
$699,000
9 Wayne Pl
Nutley, NJ
51.2
Listed by WEICHERT REALTORS
Under Contract
$749,900
82 Fischer Ave
Nutley, NJ
31.1
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Active
$599,000
90 Edison Avenue
Nutley, NJ
321,380
Listed by RE/MAX 1st ADVANTAGE
Active
$599,000
90 Edison Ave
Nutley, NJ
321,380
Listed by RE/MAX 1ST ADVANTAGE
Active
$615,000
136 Cambridge Dr
Nutley, NJ
22.11,500
Listed by THE AGENCY ONE ROCK
Active
$549,900
274 E Passaic Ave
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by PROMINENT PROPERTIES SIR
Active
$709,990
77 Columbia Ave
Nutley, NJ
21.22,056
Listed by EXP REALTY, LLC
Under Contract
$625,000
13 Cottage Pl
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS VALLEY REALTY
Active
$630,000
215 Stratford Dr
Nutley, NJ
22.1
Listed by BETTER HOMES & GARDENS EXCLUSIVE
Under Contract
$598,999
23 Princeton St
Nutley, NJ
32.1
Listed by REALTY EXECUTIVES ELITE HOMES
Under Contract
$625,000
132 Stratford Dr
Nutley, NJ
22.11,473
Listed by BROWN HARRIS STEVENS NEW JERSEY
Under Contract
$550,000
46 Highland Ave
Nutley, NJ
31
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
Active
$539,000
64 Conover Ave
Nutley, NJ
311,224
Listed by EXP REALTY, LLC
Active
$609,000
25 Kingsland St
Nutley, NJ
22
Listed by EXP REALTY, LLC
Under Contract
$599,000
59 Union Ave
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$659,000
12 Renner Avenue
Nutley, NJ
23
Listed by Keller Williams Team Realty
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$650,000
242 Prospect Street
Nutley, NJ
33
Listed by The Abbasi Agency LLC
Under Contract
$659,000
12 Renner Ave
Nutley, NJ
22.1
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS TEAM REALTY
Under Contract
$650,000
242 Prospect St
Nutley, NJ
33
Listed by THE ABBASI AGENCY
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$549,900
85 Bloomfield Avenue
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by Keller Williams Prosperity Realty
Active
$675,000
80 Brookline Ave
Nutley, NJ
42.1
Listed by COLDWELL BANKER FRANKLIN REALTY
ActiveInternet Data Exchange
$699,900
456 Hartford Drive 4057
Nutley, NJ
24
Listed by RE/MAX SELECT - Franklin Lakes
ActiveInternet Data Exchange
$710,000
11 Hampton Place
Nutley, NJ
42
Listed by Compass New Jersey, LLC-Jersey City
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$525,000
108-110 Passaic C29
Nutley, NJ
22
Listed by Compass New Jersey, LLC-Montclair
Under Contract
$525,000
108-110 Passaic Ave
Nutley, NJ
221,654
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
ActiveInternet Data Exchange
$599,000
25 Woodland Avenue
Nutley, NJ
33
Listed by Keller Williams Prosperity Realty
Active
$599,000
25 Woodland Ave
Nutley, NJ
32.1
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS PROSPERITY REALTY
See all 66 Nutley listings →

Looking for a home in Nutley?

Tell an Elevate agent who works Nutley every day what you’re after and we’ll send you homes that match — plus what they’re really selling for.

Or call (973) 440-5588.

I’m interested in
or enter your details

Free · No obligation · A local Elevate agent will reach out.

Nearby Towns We Serve

Sparta, NJNewton, NJRockaway, NJJefferson, NJDenville, NJDover, NJWayne, NJHoboken, NJStroudsburg, PABushkill, PAEaston, PABangor, PAEast Stroudsburg, PATannersville, PABlakeslee, PALake Harmony, PAVernon, NJMadison, NJMontclair, NJAlbrightsville, PACresco, PAMount Pocono, PABrodheadsville, PAPocono Lake, PAPocono Summit, PASaylorsburg, PAPalmerton, PATamiment, PADingmans Ferry, PABlairstown, NJHope, NJHackettstown, NJAllamuchy, NJChester, NJMount Olive, NJHardyston, NJHamburg, NJ
Listing data from the MLS, updated daily. What is my Nutley home worth? · Talk to an Elevate agent

Compare listings

Compare