Homes for Sale $300K to $500K in Nutley, NJ

Nutley is an Essex County township of tree-lined streets and parks, offering an easy commute to both Newark and Manhattan.

Open Full Map Search →
Get New $300K to $500K Homes In Nutley The Day They Hit The Market
Free instant alerts · Unsubscribe anytime
Homes for Sale
11
Median List Price
$438,000
Price Range
$350,000 – $499,000
County
Essex County

Browse Nutley Homes by Price

$300K – $500K (11)

By Bedrooms

2+ Bedroom (2)3+ Bedroom (9)

11 Homes for Sale $300K to $500K in Nutley, NJ

Under Contract
$350,000
38 Orchard St
Nutley, NJ
31
Listed by UNITED REAL ESTATE
Active
$409,000
25 River Rd
Nutley, NJ
31.1
Listed by BHHS FOX & ROACH
Under Contract
$489,900
10 Moore Pl
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by KELLER WILLIAMS - NJ METRO GROUP
Active
$499,000
294 Park Ave
Nutley, NJ
21.1
Listed by UNITED REAL ESTATE
Under Contract
$499,000
30 Orchard Street
Nutley, NJ
31
Listed by WEICHERT REALTORS
Active
$438,000
355-371 River Road
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by WEICHERT REALTORS
Under Contract
$495,000
12 Montclair Ave
Nutley, NJ
311,487
Listed by COMPASS NEW JERSEY LLC
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$399,990
25 River Road B11
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by Keller Williams Prosperity Realty
Under Contract
$465,000
5 Plymouth Rd
Nutley, NJ
21
Listed by MONACO REALTY LLC
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$409,000
25 River Road 3 B
Nutley, NJ
32
Listed by Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Fox & Roach Realtors - Montclair
PendingInternet Data Exchange
$350,000
38 Orchard Street
Nutley, NJ
31
Listed by United Real Estate
Search Nutley on the map →

Looking for a home in Nutley?

Tell an Elevate agent who works Nutley every day what you’re after and we’ll send you homes that match — plus what they’re really selling for.

Or call (973) 440-5588.

I’m interested in
or enter your details

Free · No obligation · A local Elevate agent will reach out.

Nearby Towns We Serve

Sparta, NJNewton, NJRockaway, NJJefferson, NJDenville, NJDover, NJWayne, NJHoboken, NJStroudsburg, PABushkill, PAEaston, PABangor, PAEast Stroudsburg, PATannersville, PABlakeslee, PALake Harmony, PAVernon, NJMadison, NJMontclair, NJAlbrightsville, PACresco, PAMount Pocono, PABrodheadsville, PAPocono Lake, PAPocono Summit, PASaylorsburg, PAPalmerton, PATamiment, PADingmans Ferry, PABlairstown, NJHope, NJHackettstown, NJAllamuchy, NJChester, NJMount Olive, NJHardyston, NJHamburg, NJ
Listing data from the MLS, updated daily. What is my Nutley home worth? · Talk to an Elevate agent

Compare listings

Compare